That’s a question that gets asked about a million times a day — and rightfully so, because SUP boards are nothing if not a major investment. Most recently it was posed on the Seabreeze Australia forum — specifically regarding the Naish 9.6 vs the Starboard 9.8 — and the answers were quite illuminating in a number of different ways, in terms not only of those two boards but also about board buying in general. Here’s the 1rst page of the three page thread (see Seabreeze Forums! – Stand Up Paddle Starboard 9’8" or Naish 9’6" for the entire thing!):
I had the pleasure of riding Brooko’s Naish 9’6" in small waves yesterday and quite liked it.( thanks Brooko) Bit tippy but once I got the sea legs working I felt quite at home on it. 
I love my Starboard 11’2" and intended to only have the one board for waves but after trying something smaller I guess I’am going to have to part with some hard earned and buy myself a Xmas present
I would love some feed back if anyone has tried the Nasih 9’6" and Starboard 9’8".
Which board would be more user freindly in smaller waves. I only have a few months surfing experience and don’t believe Ill be heading out into anything over head high, or was that 3 ft waves.
Ian
Can you demo the 9 8?? Might help your decision.
I have the 9 8 it is fantastic in small waves.
More stable at 30 inches and less nose rocker than the 9 6.
